AAUP sues Texas Tech System

- The AAUP and Texas AAUP-AFT sued Texas Tech University System leaders on July 8, challenging course-content directives on race, sex, sexual orientation and gender identity. - The complaint says the rules affected at least 277 Texas Tech courses and forced reviews of flagged material before faculty could keep teaching it. - The case, filed in the U.S. District Court in El Paso, seeks an order blocking Chancellor Brandon Creighton’s memoranda.

The American Association of University Professors and its Texas affiliate sued the Texas Tech University System on July 8, saying two directives issued by Chancellor Brandon Creighton unlawfully restrict what faculty can teach about race, sex, sexual orientation and gender identity. The complaint was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, El Paso Division, against Creighton in his official capacity and members of the system’s board of regents. The plaintiffs are asking a federal judge to declare the policies unconstitutional and block their enforcement. ### Which Texas Tech policies are at the center of the case? The lawsuit centers on two memoranda issued in December 2025 and April 2026, which the complaint calls the “Creighton Memoranda.” According to the complaint and the AAUP, those directives created a mandatory review process requiring professors to disclose whether course materials touch on prohibited subject matter involving race, sex, sexual orientation or gender identity. If a course is flagged, the instructor must stop teaching that material until the board of regents rules on it. (aaup.org) Texas Tech University System said the policies are “lawful, constitutionally sound, and fully compliant with state and federal law,” according to a statement reported by Inside Higher Ed. A system spokesperson said the system would continue its mission to deliver “rigorous academic programs, relevant coursework, and groundbreaking research.” (aaup.org) ### What does the complaint say those rules have done on campus? The complaint says the review system has already altered instruction across the system’s campuses. The AAUP and its legal team said the directives led to the banning of Plato’s *Republic* in a philosophy course, limits on first-year law instruction about race in *Dred Scott v. Sandford*, and restrictions on medical education involving racial and sexual minorities at Texas Tech health sciences campuses. (insidehighered.com) The complaint also says some professors reported that an AI tool was used to scan syllabi and reading lists for flagged content before human review. A Faculty Senate survey found the restrictions affected at least 277 courses at Texas Tech University, according to Inside Higher Ed. The same report said the system also ended gender and sexuality programs and barred students from pursuing “degree-culminating” research or theses on sexual orientation and gender identity. ### What legal claims are AAUP and Texas AAUP-AFT making? (aaup.org) The complaint brings three claims under the First and Fourteenth Amendments. The plaintiffs say the memoranda amount to viewpoint discrimination because faculty are barred from teaching some ideas about race and gender while being allowed to teach others. They also argue the policies are unconstitutionally vague, leaving professors unable to tell what is permitted, and that the directives were created and enforced in part to target Black faculty and suppress teaching about Black history and racial inequality. (insidehighered.com) Lambda Legal, the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund and Davis Wright Tremaine said they filed the suit on behalf of the AAUP and Texas AAUP-AFT. The case is styled *Texas American Association of University Professors-American Federation of Teachers et al. v. Creighton et al.*, docket number 3:26-cv-01845. (aaup.org) ### Why is El Paso in the case if this is about the Texas Tech system? The complaint says the plaintiffs are suing on behalf of members across the Texas Tech University System, including Texas Tech University, Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center, Angelo State University, Midwestern State University and Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center at El Paso. That systemwide scope is why the case reaches beyond the main Lubbock campus. (lambdalegal.org) Inside Higher Ed reported that the AAUP said last month it was investigating academic-freedom violations across Texas, including in the Texas Tech system. The new filing places that dispute into federal court and asks for declaratory and injunctive relief rather than monetary damages. ### What happens next in federal court? The July 8 filing opens the case before the Western District of Texas in El Paso, where the defendants will have to respond and the court will decide whether to grant the requested relief. (lambdalegal.org) The plaintiffs are seeking a declaration that the memoranda are unconstitutional and an order preventing Texas Tech University System leaders from enforcing them while the case proceeds. (pacermonitor.com) (insidehighered.com)

Get your own daily briefing

Scout delivers personalized news, insights, and conversations tailored to your role and industry.

Download on the App Store

Shared from Scout - Be the smartest in the room.